LTE CAT-M1 and NB-IoT are two Low Power Wide Area Network (LPWAN) technologies designed for IoT applications. While both technologies offer connectivity for IoT devices, they differ in terms of bandwidth, modes of operation, duplex mode, peak data rate, transmit power, mobility support, and more. Let’s explore the differences between these two technologies, their pros and cons, and the best IoT use cases for each.
LTE CAT-M1, also known as LTE-M or Category M1, is an LPWAN technology operating on the licensed cellular network spectrum. It provides a higher bandwidth of 1.4MHz, allowing faster data transmission than NB-IoT. CAT-M1 supports the in-band operation and offers full mobility support, making it suitable for mobile IoT devices. It also supports Voice over LTE (VoLTE) for voice communication [1].
On the other hand, NB-IoT (Narrowband IoT) is an LPWAN technology designed for low-power, low-bandwidth IoT applications. It operates on a narrow band of 200kHz, limiting its peak downlink speeds to around 26kbps in Release 13 of the 3GPP standard. NB-IoT is well-suited for indoor coverage, provides long battery life, and can accommodate a large number of devices. However, it does not support VoLTE and has limited mobility support compared to CAT-M1 [3].
Here are the key differences between LTE CAT-M1 and NB-IoT:
- Bandwidth: CAT-M1 has a wider bandwidth of 1.4MHz, while NB-IoT operates on a narrow band of 200kHz [2].
- Modes of Operation: CAT-M1 supports in-band operation, while NB-IoT supports in-band, guard-band, and standalone modes [2].
- Duplex Mode: CAT-M1 supports HD-FDD (Half Duplex Frequency Division Duplex) and FDD (Frequency Division Duplex) modes, while NB-IoT is predominantly HD-FDD, with TDD (Time Division Duplex) under discussion [2].
- Peak Data Rate: CAT-M1 offers higher peak data rates of up to 1Mbps for FDD and 375Kbps for HD-FDD, while NB-IoT has lower peak data rates of around 50kbps for HD-FDD [2].
- UL Transmit Power: CAT-M1 has a higher UL (Uplink) transmit power of 23dBm, while NB-IoT has a transmit power of 20dBm [2].
- Mobility Support: CAT-M1
Here are the IoT use-case samples that specifically focus on NB-IoT and LTE CAT-M1 technologies:
- NB-IoT (Narrowband IoT):
- Use Case: Smart Metering
- Example: NB-IoT enables utility companies to monitor energy or water consumption in real-time remotely. Smart meters equipped with NB-IoT connectivity can transmit usage data to the service provider, eliminating the need for manual meter reading and enabling more efficient billing processes.
- Reference: NB-IoT in Smart Metering
- LTE CAT-M1 (Long-Term Evolution Category M1):
- Use Case: Asset Tracking and Management
- Example: LTE CAT-M1 enables precise and continuous tracking of assets like shipping containers, vehicles, or equipment. These devices can transmit location data, operational information, and other relevant parameters to a central management platform. It enables real-time monitoring, optimization of logistics, and timely asset maintenance.
- Reference: LTE CAT-M1 for Asset Tracking
NB-IoT and LTE CAT-M1 are cellular technologies designed for low-power and wide-area IoT applications. Like other LPWAN technologies, they provide reliable connectivity, extended battery life, and support for massive IoT deployments. Another popular LPWAN technology to mention here is LoRaWAN. These technologies are particularly suitable for use cases that require long-range coverage, energy efficiency, and seamless integration with existing cellular networks.